
Venugopal P
Recent Posts

Infra Vesical outflo...
04 Dec 2024 12:58:30 PM
Spot the diagnosis a...
27 Nov 2024 04:25:15 PM
Qatar International ...
26 Nov 2024 09:16:33 PM
Asymptomatic high gr...
25 Nov 2024 07:11:42 AM
We are resuming disc...
24 Nov 2024 01:27:43 PMUrology Training even after COVID Time
Dear
All,
This
is a timely article as to how to pursue Urological Teaching and Training during
this era of COVID19.
Most
of the centres involved in Urology Training are indeed suffering because of
various factors mentioned in this article.
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/2051415820950109
The
Efforts put in by USI-ISU will have to be lauded in their efforts to keep
Urology Learning afloat during this trying time. They have with considerable
difficulty brought out several well meaning programmes to sustain Urological
education for the benefit of all. These programmes have aimed at every section
of Urologists, be it be consultants at various levels or for trainees. Many
Pharmaceutical Companies along with Corporate Sectors are conducting Programmes
apart from their help rendered to USI and ISU. But the questions that arise are
whether we are overdosing ourselves. Many of the trainees and Urologists appear
to be getting a bit tired as well in trying to attend these proliferations of such
Exercises however good it may be.
These
collective exercises do not help our trainees unless we develop local (institutional)
training which is one on one. I am sure many of the institutions have begun
this though the volume of teaching and training materials have come down. There
are centres with the inputs of trainee’s too large (thanks to MCI) where the
numbers of trainees are too large for comfort. With paucity of clinical
materials during this time, it is probably necessary to consider centres
grouping themselves and pursue clinical teaching among the group by organizing
programmes among them by the web conferencing platforms that we have now. This
will enable trainees to be exposed better.
During
this Pandemic and probably later also, it is likely that the Exit Exams will be
conducted online and such exercises within the group will help the trainees
better prepared to the nuances of online exam.
Suddenly
I find that our teacher population has mushroomed and every programme there is
teachers who are contributing to the efforts by contributing. It is really a
wonder where they were before such programmes commenced. My plea is that such
teachers who have surfaced to continue in teaching even after this pandemic is
over and when they find themselves immersed in work. Collectively the training
of the next generation can be made more fruitful. Unfortunately in India, the
teaching responsibility is solely the work of the faculty in teaching centres
but this pandemic has proven many of us wrong. The quality of teaching among
those not attached to training centres are to be considered when fashioning
programmes and by that all benefit
I am
also posting the article for those who may not be able to open the link.
I am
sure this article and my brief soliloquy will open the Pandora’s Box as to our
way of training our next generation to become better Urologists than the
previous one.
Learning
and teaching are continuous processes and there is no end for this.
With
warm regards,
Venu
Ravindra Sabnis
27 Aug 2020 10:32:59 PMCovid era has brought out some changes which we never thought will come. In normal course, we would have opposed those changes tooth & nail. But in pandemic we have not only accepted, adopted but we are recommending some of them as permanent changes.
When we talk of training the residents, Webinars, teaching classes, online mock exams, cases discussion, ...etc are ok to some extent. But these can't be substitute to a strong clinical load. Even with pathetic living conditions, why high ranking students, still prefer to take seats in govt hospitals, is only because of work load. If it was not important, posh, 7 star hospitals would have been preferred by all. Same way, online teaching is important to some extent but can't be substitute. Sir once you only said, that Amrit in high doses is poison. We need to strike the balance & keep these webinars, teaching activities as Amrit & not make it as poison.
However, one thing covid has brought out is that, those students, who lacked structured teaching activities, are immensely benefited. They got opportunity to attend classes of some of the best teachers of the country that too sitting at home. This I am sure will continue post covid as well.
I agree with you, that so many “new entrants†of teaching should continue even in post covid time. Or else they may disappear, which is not fair
As regards to exam, covid has brought out some changes in exam pattern, many principles which we observed for so many years while examining students, are now violated – due to covid. However, I feel, they should not remain post covid. Everything in life can’t be online. How candidate takes, history, examines, interprets history, reacts instantly to questions of examiner – are also important. That can’t be tested by sitting in front of computer.
So I feel covid has brought out some changes, some should continue But many things we are doing presently should disappear post covid. Trainees have to perform surgery, They have to sit in OPD, Thay have to follow up pts, Or else we will be producing theoretically top students but practically zero.